
The rest of the stories weave in and around Lucy’s Bar, and in many of them Harlin Wilder plays a part. Harlin is a hard-drinking, hard-luck man whose relationship with Grace pops up from time to time. That’s an interesting thread that gets nicely expanded in the book’s final story, but it doesn’t make this a novel. And since there’s only the one really good story, in my assessment, I’m not sure the book works terribly well as a story collection, either. Once again, though, I may be alone in this opinion. It was a New York Times Notable Book. They might be right. But I'm glad I borrowed it from the library.
Next: The Girl's Guide to Hunting and Fishing by Melissa Bank
2 comments:
There will come a time when publishers of all sizes won't feel they have to justify publishing a story collection by calling it a "novel in stories." I know they do it so they won't lose those readers who claim they don't like story collections. Readers are coming around though, I truly believe it. I do, I do...
I read this a while back and decided that many of the stories were weak. It certainly wasn't a novel in stories--more of a soap opera on paper. The idea was good, but the stories were light, without the humor of The End of the Road by Tom Bodett, which was more fun.
Post a Comment