Except the website says nothing about a reading period. It says nothing about being closed to submissions. Here, in fact, is a copy of its guidelines for writers:
* The only criterion for acceptance of material for publication in X Review is that of excellence.
* No simultaneous submission will be considered.
* No email submissions will be accepted (except for writers living abroad).
* Send submissions and all correspondence to
* A self-addressed, stamped envelope (SASE) must accompany each submission. If submitting both poetry and fiction, please send in separate envelopes with separate SASE's.
* There are no restrictions on length, style or subject matter. But we smile on originality.
* The author's name and address should appear on each poem and on the cover page of each story submitted. The author's name should appear on each page of his or her story.
* We normally respond within twelve weeks. Potential contributors are urged to subscribe to any magazine they admire enough to want them to publish their work. Publications such as X Review depend for their survival on subscribers.
* We encourage you to peruse a recent issue of X Review. These are made available to authors at the discounted price of $4.00.
This isn't the first time this has happened. And I don't mind if a journal decides it needs to close submissions early because it is overwhelmed. But out of respect for contributors, it MUST post this information on the website. This is unacceptable.